Comparison
vs Pure AI Coding
| Feature | Pure AI Coding | SuperSpec |
|---|---|---|
| Context Management | None/Manual | Automated |
| Requirements | Verbal | Structured docs |
| Task Tracking | None | Built-in tasks.md |
| Code Quality | Depends on prompts | Checklist validation |
| Documentation | None | Auto-generated |
| Session Continuity | None | sync/resume |
Real Scenario Comparison
Pure AI Coding:
User: Add user authentication
AI: OK, implementing... [generates code]
User: Wait, I want JWT not Sessions
AI: OK, changing... [regenerates]
User: Also need OAuth support
AI: OK... [modifies again]Result: Multiple rewrites, fragmented code
With SuperSpec:
/ss-create userAuth -b
# Generates structured spec
# Clarifies: auth method, providers, security requirements...
/ss-tasks
# Generates task list
# Implement one by one, orderly progress
/ss-archive
# Archive complete documentation for future referenceResult: Done once, documentation complete
vs Traditional Project Management
| Feature | JIRA/Notion | SuperSpec |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | General PM | AI dev specific |
| Granularity | Epic/Story | Single feature spec |
| AI Integration | None | Native support |
| Code Correlation | Weak/Manual | Strong/Auto |
| Learning Curve | High | Low |
SuperSpec Advantages
- Designed for AI - File size, format optimized for AI context
- Code as Docs - Specs evolve with code
- Zero Config -
superspec initand start - Local First - All data in project
vs Other Spec Tools
| Feature | Swagger/OpenAPI | Storybook | SuperSpec |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domain | API | UI Components | Full-stack |
| AI Support | None | None | Native |
| Workflow | Doc generation | Component dev | Complete flow |
| Scope | Backend | Frontend | Full-stack |
vs AI Code Review Tools
| Feature | CodeRabbit etc. | SuperSpec |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Post-PR | Pre-development |
| Focus | Code quality | Requirement completeness |
| Output | Review comments | Complete docs |
Complementary, Not Replacement
SuperSpec focuses on pre-development spec definition and during-development progress tracking:
SuperSpec → Implementation → CodeRabbit → Merge
Spec Code Review DoneWhy Choose SuperSpec
- Built for AI dev - Not a modified general tool
- Lightweight - Single CLI, no complex setup
- Open Source - MIT license, fully open
- I18n Ready - Native Chinese/English templates
- Progressive - Use only what you need
Next Steps
- Philosophy - Design principles
- Quick Start - Start using now